Political parties "illegal" in Afghanistan - Afghan Justice
Minister
25 August 2003
Democracy For Middle East
Editorial
On August 24th while in China, the Afghan Justice Minister Abdul
Rahim Karimi said: "All political
parties currently operating in Afghanistan are illegal because the transitional
government is yet to enact a
political party law."
Many friends of the Afghan President Hamid Karzai believe that Islamists such
as Karimi and Abdul Hadi
Shinwari, the Afghan Supreme Court Chief Justice, are stalling promulgation
of political party laws. It is
believed that these Islamists want to ensure Islamic warlords such as Abd' Al-Rasul
Al-Sayyaf, Ismail Khan,
and Burhan' ad-Din Rabani, Pir Gailani and Sighbatulllah Mujaddidi can easily
turn Afghanistan
into a theocracy-like state. On August 20th Karimi said that the constitution
of Afghanistan will only
permit movements recognized under Islamic law.
Currently, there are around 83 organizations active in political activities
in the country. They are running
for the country's first general elections in nearly 30 years scheduled for June
2004. All parties have
registered with the government . All party platforms support and defend democratic
principles, respect
Islamic principles, place national interest before other interests, show concern
for the war ravaged
economy, and ask for a secularized government apparatus.
The parties which have held public and open meetings include Hisb-i Wahdat-i
Milli Afghanistan led by
Sultan Mahmud Ghazi, Nohzat-i Milli Afghanistan led by Yunus Qanuni, Afghan
Millat led by Anwar al-Haq
Ahadi, Hisb-i Jamhuri Afghanistan led by Sighbatullah Sangar, and Ittehad-i
Milli Afghanistan led by Noor
al-Haq Olomi.
These parties have appealed to many Afghans who endured the civil war between
the mujahiddin guerillas
and later the Taliban regime. Many in Kabul fear the return of the Islamists
under the "Islamic Republic of
Afghanistan." These anti-Islamists parties have caused a split between
reformists and Islamist in the
Transitional Administration.
President Karzai and most of his cabinet ministers favor a secularized government
which does not totally
exclude religion but allows civil laws to run the government. The Justice Minister,
Supreme Court Chief
Justice, and regional Governors favor Islamic law which allows their monopoloy
over the lifes of people.
U.S. authorities and European diplomats are nervous in Kabul in anticipation
of the upcoming Loya Jirgah on
the constitution, national elections, and party laws.
Some European diplomats say that a compromise is being planned between the reformists
and Islamists.
However, they warn that any comprise for the Islamization of the Afghan government
will be
irreversible.
One analyst stressed that the Islamists might even be institutionalized in
such deals. This could result in
failure of western principles of democracy for Afghanistan. This is something
which both the
"Islamic Republic" of Iran and Pakistan want to prevent both in Afghanistan
and Iraq.
In a sign of the concern, a delegation from the Congress led by Senator John
McCain raised the issue
last week. On his way to a meeting in Pakistan with President Pervez Musharraf,
Mr. McCain told
journalists in Kabul that Pakistan was "not doing as much as it can"
to stem the cross-border
infiltration...We are appreciative of the help that Pakistan has given us in
the war on terror and in
other ways, but we believe that more measures can be taken."
In recent weeks, there are rumors that Al-Qaida cells operation in the tribal
belt of Pakistan have moved
through Iran and into Iraq. Unlike Iraq, where the UN works in the shadow of
a US protectorate and suffers
the consequences the UN Assistance Mission in Afghanistan shoulders a mandate
that includes relief,
peacekeeping, institution-building and evolving the instruments of democracy
as envisaged at the Bonn
conference.